The Best Toilet Paper

Your guide to this review today is by Cleaning expert Ben Murray
Published on
February 19th, 2019

Expert BioExpert Bio

Ben’s formal training and certifications in cleaning include the ASD (Advanced Structural Drying), AMRT (Applied Microbial Remediation Technician),
WRT (Water restoration technician), CCT (Carpet Cleaning technician), and bio hazard cleanup, as well as several other certifications from the IICRC. Ben has managed teams involved in cleaning projects around the United States. Ben’s passion for cleaning dates all the way back to keeping his rugby gear tidy while a young lad. Ben holds an undergraduate degree from Oxford, a Master’s degree from Oxford, and a mountain of hands on experience at the school of hard knocks.

The Cleaning Institute

Toilet paper is a necessity to use on a daily basis and is essential when using the restroom. Toilet paper is not created equal and can vary on its quality and value depending on the brand that is used. We reviewed a few types of toilet paper to determine the best products to use while spending time in the loo. Our top pick is the Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper, which has a silky and smooth texture that feels luxurious and is high-quality. It proves to be a premium product due to its thick texture that is easy to flush. Our honorable mention award goes to the Amazon Brand – Presto! 308-Sheet Mega Roll Toilet Paper, which is 80 percent thicker and stronger than some of the top leading brands. It’s also a green option because the paper is sourced from sustainably managed forests. The Seventh Generation Toilet Paper is our green pick that is favored for its soft texture and strength. The bath tissue is eco-friendly and is constructed from 100 percent paper.

Testing Categories

With our years of experience, we created a few different categories during the tests that we performed, which were used to rate each product and determine its overall quality and value.

Quality: We evaluated the quality of each toilet paper product that we tested by examining its strength and construction. The overall quality influenced its value and how durable it was with each use.

Texture: Texture is one of the top qualities of the toilet paper that we tested because it determined how comfortable it was to use. We took a look at how soft or rough the paper was, which influenced how we rated it. The construction of the bath tissue was also a contributing factor.

Strength: The strength of the toilet paper is another factor we considered to determine if it could hold up well without having to use too much paper in one use. We also tested how easily the toilet paper ripped off of the roll, and took it into consideration when rating.

Top Pick

Quilted Northern
Ultra Plush
Toilet Paper

The Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper provides durability and strength with three silky layers of comfort. It offers a clean feel that is comfortable with a soft texture.

Price Check

Most notable upside: Quilted Northern proves to provide durable toilet paper that won’t fall apart easily upon contact. The product doesn’t feel like sandpaper or leave behind any lint or residue, which promotes proper hygiene and prevents messes. The product is septic-safe and easy to flush without the risk of clogging that can occur. Using less toilet paper due to its durability also means that less paper needs to be flushed each time. It’s also Sustainable Forestry Initiative certified. The pack of bath tissue includes 24 rolls, which is equivalent to over 94 regular rolls. Each roll has 319 sheets, which makes it easy to change the roll less often. The rolls can easily fit on a standard dispenser. It’s also easy to rip off each piece of toilet paper. The layers are extremely absorbent, which means that less toilet paper needs to be used. The paper also includes a decorative pattern. The fluff and cushion of the bath tissue makes it soft to the touch and prevents irritation that can occur with frequent use, especially in one sitting.

Biggest downsides: he paper is narrow despite being advertised as equivalent to four regular rolls. The large size and radius of each roll can also make it difficult to fit on an average dispenser. The product has a tendency not to dissolve after 30 minutes once it gets wet, which can lead to clogs that occur over time.

Honorable Mention

Amazon Brand - Presto!
308-Sheet Mega Roll
Toilet Paper

The Presto! 308-Sheet Mega Roll Toilet Paper includes 24 mega rolls with 308 2-ply sheets per roll. It’s up to 80 percent thicker and more durable than other brands.

Price Check

Most notable upside: The product doesn’t have a tendency to clog toilets when it’s flushed. It’s soft to the touch and lasts longer than most products. The product is safe to flush down the toilet and is also an eco-friendly option because it’s constructed from sustainably managed forests and controlled sources. The product is made by Amazon and can be refunded if the customer is not fully satisfied. It’s PEFC certified due to the pulp material that it’s constructed from. The paper is also designed to last up to four times longer than a standard roll of toilet paper for added savings and less waste. The Pesto! brand proves to have better tear resistance for added convenience. The rolls are larger than similar products on the market, which allow them to last longer without having to replace the toilet paper as frequently. The soft texture makes it comfortable to use and doesn’t cause it to feel abrasive on the skin. Although it’s soft, it’s not at risk of having your fingers break through when using the paper due to its strong construction and texture. Small designs are also imprinted onto the paper, which increases its appeal.

Biggest downsides: The toilet paper disintegrates quickly when coming into contact with liquid. The paper tends to leave fibers behind. It also has a rougher texture compared to other leading toilet paper brands.

Green Pick

Seventh
Generation
Toilet Paper

The Seventh Generation Toilet Paper is 2-ply bathroom tissue that is not only durable but is also eco-friendly for those who want to reduce their carbon footprint.

Price Check

Most notable upside: The toilet paper is a green-friendly product that is safe to use and doesn’t include an unusual odor or scent as a fragrance-free product. It’s made from 100 percent recycled paper without any added dyes, fragrances, or inks added, which makes it safe to have contact with while using the restroom. The bath tissue even has a minimum of 50 percent post-consumer content. It’s only whitened with products that are safe without the use of chlorine. The brand is convenient to use in different settings because it’s septic-safe and can be flushed down low-flow toilets, which are commonly found in campers and RVs. Included in the package is two 24-roll packs, which is equivalent to 48 toilet paper rolls or 240 sheets per roll. It’s allergen-free and is safe to use without worrying about coming in contact with harmful chemicals or toxins.

Biggest downsides: The paper is thinner than other toilet papers that aren’t eco-friendly, and also has a rougher texture. It is also prone to shredding if it’s not handled gently. The butterfly print on the product looks dated and can be too feminine or decorative for some consumers. All of the toilet paper is packaged together without being individually wrapped.

All Our Picks

Tips for Effective Toilet Paper

The quality of toilet paper that is used when spending time in the restroom determines how comfortable the individual feels with maintaining proper hygiene. The best type of toilet paper includes multiple layers to ensure that it’s thick enough to get the job done. Thicker bath tissue also prevents less paper from having to be used with each wipe to ensure that a little goes a long way. The toilet paper should hold up easily without leaving behind lint or tearing easily with each use. It should also be easy to flush down the toilet without clogging and is safe for the septic system.

A Note About Safety and Storage

Toilet paper can be stored in a clean, dry area where it isn’t at risk of becoming wet to avoid potential damage or contamination. It can be placed in a location that is easy to access close to the toilet, which includes under the sink or in a storage cabinet in the room. Keep the toilet paper sealed in the packaging until it’s time to use each roll to protect the paper from dirt or dust that can settle onto the surface.

The Best Toilet Paper

Your guide to this review today is by Cleaning expert Ben Murray

The Cleaning Institute

Testing Categories

Quilted Northern
Ultra Plush
Toilet Paper

Amazon Brand - Presto!
308-Sheet Mega Roll
Toilet Paper

Seventh
Generation
Toilet Paper

All Our Picks

Quilted Northern
Ultra Plush
Toilet Paper

Amazon Brand - Presto!
308-Sheet Mega Roll
Toilet Paper

Seventh
Generation
Toilet Paper

Tips for Effective Toilet Paper

A Note About Safety and Storage

Quick Links

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

The Best Toilet Paper

Your guide to this review today is by Cleaning expert Ben Murray

The Cleaning Institute

Testing Categories

Quilted NorthernUltra Plush Toilet Paper

Amazon Brand - Presto! 308-Sheet Mega Roll Toilet Paper

SeventhGeneration Toilet Paper

All Our Picks

Quilted NorthernUltra Plush Toilet Paper

Amazon Brand - Presto! 308-Sheet Mega Roll Toilet Paper

SeventhGeneration Toilet Paper

Tips for Effective Toilet Paper

A Note About Safety and Storage

Quick Links

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Quilted Northern
Ultra Plush
Toilet Paper

Amazon Brand - Presto!
308-Sheet Mega Roll
Toilet Paper

Seventh
Generation
Toilet Paper

Quilted Northern
Ultra Plush
Toilet Paper

Amazon Brand - Presto!
308-Sheet Mega Roll
Toilet Paper

Seventh
Generation
Toilet Paper