The Best Chest for Dog Toys

Your guide to this review today is by Cleaning expert Ben Murray
Published on
March 29th, 2019

Expert BioExpert Bio

Ben’s formal training and certifications in cleaning include the ASD (Advanced Structural Drying), AMRT (Applied Microbial Remediation Technician),
WRT (Water restoration technician), CCT (Carpet Cleaning technician), and bio hazard cleanup, as well as several other certifications from the IICRC. Ben has managed teams involved in cleaning projects around the United States. Ben’s passion for cleaning dates all the way back to keeping his rugby gear tidy while a young lad. Ben holds an undergraduate degree from Oxford, a Master’s degree from Oxford, and a mountain of hands on experience at the school of hard knocks.

The Cleaning Institute

Lurking in every crack and crevice around your home is one of the biggest contributors to clutter of all time – dog toys. We’ve all been there – no matter how many toys you throw out, they seem to reappear to take over every inch of floor and cabinet space. Not to fear though – we can help you find the perfect solution to your action figure conundrum. We scoured the market to find the picture perfect chest for dog toys that will not only provide a clever hideaway, but that will also add style to your home. All of our expectations were met when we stumbled upon the Otto & Ben Storage Ottoman. What a find! It has plenty of space neatly disguised as a modern footrest or bench. We should also mention 3 Sprouts Kids Toy Chest, which offers function and is cute as a button. Let’s not forget our environmentally friendly favorite option, OrganizerLogic Burlap Basket. No matter what your budget or home needs, we have your back.

Testing Categories

Design- One of the most important elements of choosing a dog toy organizer, product design plays a big role in choosing the right item to fit your home. How much can fit inside? Are the toys well hidden inside? These are some of the questions we put to the test regarding the design of each product.

Durability- Even if you have a small dog, they’re probably tough on storage bins. When being placed around dogs, we understand that organizational items need a certain level of strength in order to endure whatever comes their way.

Aesthetics- Any old bucket can hold toys – the real challenge comes in trying to transform the clutter into a stylish part of your home. Although looks were not a deciding factor, it did give each chest examined a leg up from the competition if it looked good on top of being useful.

Dog Friendliness- As mentioned before, it is essential for any product used by, and for, dogs to be safe and easy to use. Especially for a toy chest, we paid extra close attention to each minute detail to ensure that each item was approved for dog use at any age.

Maneuverability- A home with dogs is constantly changing. This is why we thought it would be good to see how easy it was to move around each toy chest, both with and without the toys inside. Reorganizing is a never ending battle, so why not opt for a product that can be shifted with minimal effort?

Top Pick

Otto &
Ben 30"
Storage Ottoman

A neat and stylish hideaway for your dog's toys or anything else lying around the house. The best of both worlds, stay on top of clutter while using this clever footrest.

Price Check

The clear winner in the toy chest category, as its well designed ottoman style helps it blend seamlessly into any home setting. Inside, the otto is spacious enough to hold not only toys, but we also found it useful for storing extra blankets, pillows, or any other loose items in need of out of the way storage. Setup was super easy and took only seconds to unfold. However, it was still stable once constructed, so it didn’t feel flimsy when used as a bench or foot rest. We also liked that it comes in 3 different colors, which makes it easier to match your interior. The foam padding isn’t too thick, but it still provides a little added comfort when kicking up your feet and provided a soft landing for smaller children. All in all, it is a very well rounded product that checks all the right boxes.

Most notable upside: Folds up for easy storage when not in use and it holds up to 250 lbs. It has an easy to follow setup and is sturdy enough to be modified, like adding feet.

Biggest downsides: The lid not as sturdy as the base, and fraying may occur. This is not an ideal chest to leave your dog with unsupervised.

Honorable Mention

3 Sprouts
Kids
Toy Chest

Adorable animals on every box catch the eye while reducing clutter.

Price Check

This kid specific toy chest was too cute to pass up for our honorable mention. We loved the specific detail to kid friendly features, like the handle on the lid, which is specially designed for little hands. 3 Sprouts also chose a nice, durable fabric for construction, so it is rough and tumble enough to be stored in a child’s room, not to mention that it is easily cleanable. Great for toys, books, and it could even be used as a laundry hamper or towel storage in a child’s bathroom.

Most notable upside: Lightweight and movable, with many different animals to choose from. It is also soft and dependable.

Biggest downsides: It does not always hold shape and may not hold up if your dog tries to climb on it. It also has a childish design, which may not be appealing for use for your dog. It also needs to air out after opening.

Green Pick

Organizer Logic
Burlap Storage
Organizer Basket

Burlap equals durability in this amazing storage basket. Built for heavy duty work, this organizer can house just about anything with no complaints.

Price Check

Our favorite green option is made by OrganizerLogic. This burlap bag is not only Earth friendly, but was also the easiest to move once full due to its sturdy bracket handles. When empty, it folds smoothly down for easy storage. The inside has a plastic liner that helps keep away dust, dirt, and moisture. We also liked the labels, which were clearly marked on the side to help remind little ones what goes in each container. It also worked great as a general basket for a quick clean up, or to move or store random odds and ends. This would make a great addition to any toddler’s household.

Most notable upside: Super durable, even with bulky items, this product is versatile. Better yet, if your dog tries to climb on it, they will not damage this tote.

Biggest downsides: It has no lid to close in items, and it may need to air out after it is unpackaged. The inner wireframe could become a safety hazard if you dog chews a hole into the tote and pulls it out.

The Best Chest for Dog Toys

Your guide to this review today is by Cleaning expert Ben Murray

The Cleaning Institute

Testing Categories

Otto &
Ben 30"
Storage Ottoman

3 Sprouts
Kids
Toy Chest

Organizer Logic
Burlap Storage
Organizer Basket

All Our Picks

Otto &
Ben 30"
Storage Ottoman

3 Sprouts
Kids
Toy Chest

Organizer Logic
Burlap Storage
Organizer Basket

Quick Links

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

The Best Chest for Dog Toys

Your guide to this review today is by Cleaning expert Ben Murray

The Cleaning Institute

Testing Categories

Otto & Ben 30" Storage Ottoman

3 Sprouts Kids Toy Chest

Organizer LogicBurlap StorageOrganizer Basket

All Our Picks

Otto & Ben 30" Storage Ottoman

3 Sprouts Kids Toy Chest

Organizer LogicBurlap StorageOrganizer Basket

Quick Links

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Otto &
Ben 30"
Storage Ottoman

3 Sprouts
Kids
Toy Chest

Organizer Logic
Burlap Storage
Organizer Basket

Otto &
Ben 30"
Storage Ottoman

3 Sprouts
Kids
Toy Chest

Organizer Logic
Burlap Storage
Organizer Basket